Observación (CEACR) - Adopción: 2000, Publicación: 89ª reunión CIT (2001)

Convenio sobre el derecho de sindicación y de negociación colectiva, 1949 (núm. 98) - Malasia (Ratificación : 1961)

1.  The Committee notes the information provided by the Government in its report, and the supplementary information forwarded.

2.  For a number of years the Committee has been commenting on the need to repeal section 15 of the Industrial Relations Act (IRA) which limits the scope of collective agreements for companies granted "pioneer status". Since 1994, the Government has indicated to the Committee that the provision was in the process of being repealed; however, the Committee notes that, according to the Government, the repealing legislation has been inadvertently delayed in order to accommodate other amendments to the Act, so that the Act could meet the rapidly changing work environment. Given that section 15 of the IRA constitutes a violation of Article 4 of the Convention, and that six years have passed since the Government indicated that the appropriate amendments would be made, the Committee urges the Government to ensure there are no further delays in repealing section 15, and to forward a copy of the repealing legislation as soon as it is adopted.

3.  With respect to the Committee’s previous comments concerning the restrictions on collective bargaining contained in section 13(3) of the IRA, the Committee notes that the Government reiterates its view that issues pertaining to such things as transfer, dismissal and reinstatement essentially refer to individual rights which could not be predetermined in a collective agreement, since this would affect the rights of management to manage. The Committee must again recall that issues such as transfer, dismissal and reinstatement should not be excluded from the scope of collective bargaining. While a collective agreement would not normally deal with individual cases of transfer, dismissal and reinstatement, it should be possible to include for example, as is often found in the collective agreements in many countries, the general criteria and procedures concerning these issues. The Committee urges the Government to amend the legislation to bring section 13(3) into full conformity with Article 4 of the Convention.

4.  A further provision of the IRA has also been a subject of comment for many years, namely section 52, which provides for certain restrictions on the right to bargain collectively for public servants, other than those engaged in the administration of the State. Lacking detailed information, the Committee has not been in a position to determine whether genuine collective bargaining exists in this sector or merely consultation. In this regard, the Government again points to the role of the national joint councils in providing an avenue for discussion and negotiation on terms and conditions of employment, including salaries, of public servants. While the Committee has in the past noted this information, it once more requests the Government to provide specific information on how collective bargaining is encouraged and promoted in practice between public employers and public servants. In particular, the Committee would welcome information on the number of employees covered, and the specific issues discussed. The Committee again requests the Government to provide this information as well as examples of the process that has been followed to reach specific collective agreements for public servants.

5.  The Committee requests the Government to indicate in its next report the steps taken or envisaged to bring the abovementioned provisions into full conformity with the Convention.